Are Marijuana Stocks Generally Overvalued?

The past several months have been incredible ones for marijuana stocks. Although many of them have been around for years, nationwide legalization in Canada and legalization progress in the United States has thrust a large handful of cannabis stocks like Canopy Growth (NYSE:CGC), Aurora Cannabis (NYSE:ACB) and Tilray (NASDAQ:TLRY) in the spotlight. It has also pushed most of these stocks much higher.

Click to Enlarge
Source: Shutterstock

The sheer speed and scope prompts a huge question most investors have avoided asking, however — are marijuana stock overvalued?

They are.

InvestorPlace - Stock Market News, Stock Advice & Trading Tips

There’s more to the answer than just the acknowledgment though. Namely, being overvalued isn’t the same thing as calling these companies a sham. It also doesn’t preclude gains in the meantime that will make them even more overvalued, even beyond typical measures of value like price-to-earnings ratios or cash flow potential. It’s not unfair to “value” this industry’s players solely based on the premise for the time being.

Nevertheless, at some point in time these organizations will have to justify their stunningly frothy prices. Once the market realizes they can’t, that’s when the wave of right-pricing begins.

Experts Sound Off

It’s undeniable that the pro-cannabis movement is gaining traction. Canada is completely on board, even if its retail choices are modest. Meanwhile, marijuana is now legal for one reason or another in ten U.S. states. The light at the end of the tunnel has set most marijuana stocks on fire, and for good reason. Not only does legalization represent more opportunity, it has made them potential acquisition targets.

• 10 Stocks That Every 20-Year-Old Should Buy

That doesn’t mean investors have remained rational about the whole premise though.

Consider something Canopy Growth CEO Bruce Linton said just late last week:

“I think it’s entirely true that cannabis has become frothy and I’m not saying that necessarily specifically about our [stock]. But you could list 85 or 90 names that are probably publicly listed that I as the operator of one of the first and most dominant [companies] have never heard of those companies.”

Again, that’s from Bruce Linton, chief of Canopy Growth, and someone who has much to gain by not suggesting anything close to what he said.

Linton isn’t the only insider or industry expert to point out concern, however, that early pot investors have gotten ahead of themselves. Bethany Gomez, managing director at Brightfield Group, commented in a recent interview:

“Another full third of consumers who are not purchasing through the retail market yet have cited pricing as one of their key concerns … that pricing differential between the recreational market and the black market … the market is really missing those mid to lower income cannabis consumers which are a significant portion of that population.”

In other words, a good-sized swath of would-be tokers — and suppliers — are still circumventing the legalized arm of the industry. Investors were pricing marijuana stocks as if the illegal side of the trade would shift to legal operations. One can’t invest in the unregulated, illegal swath of the marijuana business that clearly still exists, and still competes with publicly traded outfits in the cannabis industry.

Jon Najarian, co-founder of Investitute, was a little more blunt about the matter in September of last year, commenting on the wild runup of most marijuana stocks “This is just stupid time. I can’t believe the valuations at this stage.”

Little has changed, valuation-wise, since then.

All the Telltale Signs

Even beyond the expert opinions though, the ancillary evidence of froth among these stocks is in place.

No two bubbles are quite the same, but they all eventually sport the same core warning signs that are in place now. One of those warning signs in place now is, everyone and their uncle is talking about investing in marijuana … including people who’ve never actually invested a penny in their lives.